Every validator message has a level. It decides whether the invoice counts as accepted or rejected — but not on its own whether the invoice is in order for tax purposes.
The three levels
| Level | Meaning | Result in the KoSIT check |
|---|---|---|
| Error | a mandatory rule is broken | recommendation: reject |
| Warning | a "should" rule is broken | recommendation: accept |
| Information | for information only | recommendation: accept |
This is how KoSIT's report works: if there is at least one message at level error, the recommendation is "reject", otherwise "accept". A file for which no matching check was found is rejected as well.
The level depends on the validator
The same rule can have a different level in different checks. KoSIT lowers some rules in its configuration, e.g. units of measure (BR-CL-23) to warning. Another validator reports the same rule as an error. Peppol rules such as PEPPOL-EN16931-R120 are partly only warnings in XRechnung.
Our report shows the level as KoSIT's configuration sets it.
What the German Ministry of Finance says
The BMF letter of 15 Oct 2025 distinguishes:
- Format errors (para. 6a): the file does not follow the permitted syntax. Then it is not an e-invoice but an "other invoice".
- Business rule errors (para. 6b): data is missing or contradictory, e.g. BT-10 is missing or the VAT amount does not match the rate.
- Legal consequences (para. 35a): breaches of the mandatory invoice details under §§ 14(4) and 14a UStG make the invoice improper. In contrast, business rule errors on other content (e.g. the missing field "BT-10 Buyer reference") do not matter for VAT.
So an error in the report does not automatically make the invoice invalid for VAT — and a clean check does not mean all details are right. According to the BMF, validation does not replace the recipient's duty to check the invoice, but one can rely on the technical result of a suitable validation application, and it is advisable to keep the validation report.
Which errors matter for tax is a tax question — clarify it case by case with your tax adviser.
And the recipient?
Whether a recipient rejects an invoice with errors is up to them. The result of a check is a recommendation — that is how the state of Baden-Württemberg describes its e-invoice validator: "a recommendation on acceptance or rejection".
Sources: KoSIT, validator configuration XRechnung 3.0.2 (report, levels); BMF letter of 15 Oct 2025, paras. 6a, 6b, 35a; BITBW, documentation of the e-invoice validator (15 Jan 2026).