ZUGFeRD (Factur-X in France) comes in several profiles. They differ in how much data the XML holds — and so in whether the invoice is an e-invoice in Germany and which rules it is checked by.
Which profiles are e-invoices
According to the VAT application decree (UStAE section 14.1 (14), as of 15 Oct 2025), ZUGFeRD from version 2.0.1 — except the profiles MINIMUM and BASIC-WL — is a permitted e-invoice format.
| Profile | E-invoice in Germany? | Checked by |
|---|---|---|
| MINIMUM | no | — |
| BASIC WL | no | — |
| BASIC | yes | FeRD rules for BASIC |
| EN 16931 (COMFORT) | yes | EN 16931 rules |
| EXTENDED | yes | FeRD rules for EXTENDED |
| XRECHNUNG | yes | XRechnung rules (KoSIT) |
The Factur-X 1.09.2 / ZUGFeRD 2.5.2 specification explicitly forbids MINIMUM and BASIC WL when seller and buyer are in Germany (rules BR-HYBRID-DE-01 and BR-HYBRID-DE-02). Older versions (e.g. ZUGFeRD 1.0) are not covered by the UStAE statement.
ZUGFeRD is not XRechnung
FeRD writes in its FAQ (in German) that a valid ZUGFeRD EN16931 or EXTENDED invoice can produce error messages when checked only by XRechnung rules, without the invoice being faulty or legally inadmissible; the format used must be validated by the rule set meant for it.
Typical messages are then BR-DE-21 or BR-DE-15 (buyer reference missing), although the profile does not require these details.
How our check handles this
We choose the rules by the profile stated in the invoice (BT-24):
- XRechnung and EN 16931: official check with KoSIT's validator.
- BASIC and EXTENDED: KoSIT's configuration has no check for these profiles; we check by FeRD's rules (with Mustang) and say so in the report.
- MINIMUM and BASIC WL: the report points out that this is not an e-invoice in Germany.
What to do
Ask the recipient which format they expect. If they require XRechnung, there is also the ZUGFeRD profile XRECHNUNG. Otherwise ZUGFeRD from version 2.0.1 in the profile BASIC, EN 16931 or EXTENDED is an e-invoice under the UStAE.
Sources: BMF letter of 15 Oct 2025 (UStAE 14.1 (14)); Factur-X 1.09.2 / ZUGFeRD 2.5.2 (rules BR-HYBRID-DE-01, -02); FeRD, ZUGFeRD FAQ; KoSIT, validator configuration XRechnung 3.0.2.